Chapoutier Ermitage 'Le Pavillon' Rouge 2004
"Withdrawn bouquet - some suggestion of red fruits, and propensity to become gamey, sous-bois/damp forest in time. Holds a cool air at this stage (turns out to be Pavillon, so no surprise). Quality of fruit apparent here. Its axis is black, peppery fruit. Has rich theme in the understated 2004 style, and a mineral aftertaste. 2021-24."
- John Livingstone-Learmouth, The Wines of the Northern Rhone

"Ratcheting up the level of concentration is the 2004 Ermitage Le Pavillon. Its deep ruby/purple color is accompanied by sweet aromas of blackberries, cherries, licorice, and minerals. Medium-bodied, with lovely purity and a long finish. It will age well for 15 years."
- 91-94/100 Robert Parker

"Ruby-red. Vibrant raspberry and cherry skin scents are enlivened by zesty mineral and floral accents. Structured and chewy, with well-focused red fruit flavors, excellent depth and a graceful, silky texture on the finish. There’s a striking and impressive mix of bright and rich tones here. This comes from the lieu-dit Bessards." - 93/100 Stephen Tanzer